Are Some Doctors More Prone to Medical Malpractice Than Others?

Members of Stanford University School of Medicine and Stanford Law School have recently released the results of a study that used 10-years’ worth of statistics to complete. What were they trying to find that required a decade of numbers, facts, and evidence? The purpose was to analyze paid medical malpractice claims to determine if certain behaviors, or even just certain medical practitioners, were more prone to harming patients than others. The results can be considered telling, if not alarming.

The data used for the study was collected from the National Practitioner Data Bank, and more than 66,000 paid claims were reviewed. Nearly 55,000 physicians were included in the information, which was timestamped from 2005 to 2014. At a cursory glance, it is already clear that a great deal of physicians were sued for and lost a medical malpractice claim more than once in 10 years.

To get into the specifics, about 1% of all the physicians included in the study accounted for roughly 1/3 of all the paid claims. This number is staggering when extrapolated worldwide. Imagine this ratio in other terms: what if 1% of the criminal population could be linked to 33% of all crimes? Clearly something would have to be done to correct their behaviors.

The Dangers of Repeat Medical Malpractice Offenders

When the numbers were examined even further, an upsetting pattern began to emerge. 84% of all physicians had lost a suit once during the study timeframe, 16% were responsible for at least two claims, and 4% had paid three or more claims, which accounted for roughly 12% of all claims. The data suggests that the more previous claims there are against a doctor, the more likely that doctor will have a claim in the future.

But what does that mean? More or less, penalties exacted against negligent doctors who hurt patients through medical malpractice are not effective enough. Not only do they not seem to learn from their mistakes but they are also allowed to continue their practice, despite the injuries they have caused to patients. It should also be noted the study had only focused on paid claims. There could be any number of unpaid and unreported medical malpractice incidents that could have further exposed the dangers of negligence in the hospital, clinic, or pharmacy.

[The New England Journal of Medicine has a summary of the study to be found here.]

If you or a loved one has been hurt by medical malpractice in Missouri or Arkansas, Johnson, Vorhees & Martucci can help you build a claim that accounts for all of your damages. Our medical malpractice attorneys in Joplin and Springfield have 140+ years of collective experience, only collect a paycheck if you collect a settlement, and offer free initial consultations. Call 417.313.1130 today!



Click on the button below to fill out our free initial consultation form and one of our team members will reach out to gather more information.

    • Please enter your name.
    • This isn't a valid phone number.
      Please enter your phone number.
    • This isn't a valid email address.
      Please enter your email address.
    • Please make a selection.
    • Please enter a message.